Property tax appeal comparison · 2026

Ownwell vs AppealMyTax

Ownwell takes 25–35% of your savings every year. We charge $49 flat. You do the math.

Them

Ownwell

Contingency — 25% of savings in TX/IL, 35% in CA/NY/FL

$194–$271 per year

25% × $774 average annual savings = $194 (TX) or 35% × $774 = $271 (FL/CA/NY). Every year. Forever.

Coverage

TX, FL, CA, NY, IL, GA (Ownwell). TX, FL (us — CA/NY launching).

Us

AppealMyTax

Flat-fee packet, no contingency, no recurring cut.

$49 flat

One-time. You keep 100% of your savings every year. Or upgrade to $199-$249 Done-For-You for hands-off filing.

Coverage

TX (Harris County live, all 21 counties listed) + FL (67 counties — calculator live as ETL completes)

Real-world cost comparison

Typical Florida homeowner — $50K overassessment, $430/yr savings

Annual savings on appeal

$430

Ownwell cost

$150 (35% × $430)

$280/yr after their cut, repeating

AppealMyTax cost

$49 one-time

$430/yr — every year

Multi-year math

10-year math: Ownwell takes ~$1,500 in contingency fees over a decade (assuming flat savings — actual fees grow as Save Our Homes compounds). Our $49 fee captures the same reduction with the same Save Our Homes protection. You keep $1,450 more.

Ownwell— pros & cons

Strengths

  • Hands-off — they handle the protest filing and hearing for you
  • $50M Series B funding (Feb 2026), 500K+ clients, proven 86% success rate
  • Coverage in TX, FL, CA, NY, IL, GA, expanding nationally

Limitations

  • Takes a percentage of YOUR savings every year (compounds against you)
  • 35% contingency in Florida/California/New York is steep
  • Hard to escalate if they don't pursue your case aggressively
  • No transparency on which comparables they used or how they argued the case

Why AppealMyTax wins

  • Flat $49 packet — you keep 100% of the savings, every year
  • You own the filing record and can escalate to circuit court yourself
  • We show you the exact comparable evidence and let you tune it
  • Florida Save Our Homes compounds: a one-time $49 packet protects your savings for 10+ years
  • $199-$249 Done-For-You tier if you want hands-off — still cheaper than Ownwell year 1, and zero recurring cut

Try it free

Search your address. Get your specific overassessment estimate in 30 seconds. No credit card.

Check my address — Free

The free check is genuinely free. Optional $49 packet only if you want a pre-filled iFile-ready protest letter.

See other comparisons