Property tax appeal comparison · 2026
AppealSeal vs AppealMyTax
AppealSeal charges $100 flat for a California-only packet you file yourself. Our $49 Audit has different deliverables and evidence-dependent availability, and show you your overpayment and comps free first.
Them
AppealSeal
Flat $100 one-time packet, California only, you file it yourself (Prop 8 decline-in-value)
$100 flat
AppealSeal and AppealMyTax run the same kind of model, a flat-fee evidence packet you file yourself, with no cut of your savings. The two real differences are price and where each one works. AppealSeal is $100 flat and serves California only, built around the Prop 8 BOE-305-AH decline-in-value appeal (appealseal.com, retrieved July 2026). AppealMyTax is $49 flat, about half the price, for the states we carry real parcel data in, and you see your assessment comparison and your real comps free in 30 seconds before you pay.
Coverage
California only, Prop 8 decline-in-value (AppealSeal, retrieved July 2026). 7 states with real parcel data (Colorado, Florida, Illinois, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Texas), about 22.8M properties (us).
Us
AppealMyTax
Flat-fee packet, no contingency, no recurring cut.
$49 flat
One time. You keep 100% of your savings every year. Ownwell keeps 25-35%, O'Connor keeps half. See your assessment comparison free first, no signup.
Coverage
Real per-parcel assessment data in 7 states, about 22.8M properties: Colorado, Florida, Illinois, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Texas. Deepest in Florida (all 67 counties) and Texas (HCAD iFile-ready), plus a full statutory appeal guide for Georgia.
Real-world cost comparison
Homeowner with a $40K overassessment and about $600/yr in savings
Annual savings on appeal
$600
AppealSeal cost
$100 flat packet, California only, you file it yourself
$600/yr, minus $100, and only if your home is in California
AppealMyTax cost
$49 flat packet, you file it yourself
Hypothetical savings minus $49 for this purchase; not a predicted outcome
Multi-year math
Compare separate appeal years, with fresh evidence and any new product purchases included. Our $49 price is per purchase, not a lifetime service. Repeated savings are hypothetical; DIY and managed services can produce different outcomes. Government fees and preparation time are additional.
AppealSeal: pros & cons
Strengths
- ✓ Flat, honest pricing ($100 per packet), no contingency and no cut of your savings, the same philosophy as us
- ✓ Purpose-built for California Prop 8 decline-in-value appeals, a state we do not cover
- ✓ Generates an assessor-ready comparable-sales packet you file yourself and keep 100% of the savings
- ✓ Free market-analysis check before you buy
Limitations
- ✗ California only, so it cannot help a Texas, Florida, or other out-of-state homeowner at all
- ✗ $100 flat is about double our $49 for a different self-service product
- ✗ New and small (launched April 2026), with a limited track record versus established filers
- ✗ California-only scope; compare its deliverables with our national $29 guide, which requires your own evidence
Why AppealMyTax wins
- ★ Same flat-fee, file-it-yourself model at $49 instead of $100, about half the price, and you keep 100% of the savings either way
- ★ Real parcel data across 7 states with real parcel data, about 22.8M properties rather than a single state
- ★ See your assessment comparison and your actual comparable parcels free in 30 seconds, no signup, no email, before you pay
- ★ Every comp in our packet is a real, checkable parcel in your county's own appraisal roll, refunded in full if any comp is not verifiable
Try it free
Search your address. Get your specific overassessment estimate in 30 seconds. No credit card.
Check my address · FreeThe free check is genuinely free: no signup, no email. The complete $49 Property Assessment Audit includes filing-ready evidence when supported, or a valuation report when it is not.
Would you rather someone just handled it?
Our packet is for people who want to file it themselves and keep every dollar. If you would rather hand the whole thing off, these firms work on contingency: they take a cut of what they save you, and nothing if they lose. We are not affiliated with any of them.
- Visit Ownwell →OwnwellTX, CA, WA, GA, FL, IL, NY, CO, PA25% of your savings in TX, IL and NY, 35% in CA and FL. Nothing if they don't win.
- Visit Abode Money →Abode MoneyTX, FL$99 per year flat. No percentage of your savings.
- Visit Home Tax Shield →Home Tax ShieldTX$30 per property per year, plus 30% of your savings each year.
- Visit Texas Protax →Texas ProtaxTX40% of residential savings, $50 minimum per parcel. Austin and Central Texas, San Antonio and Greater Houston.
- Visit Five Stone Tax →Five Stone TaxTX40% of your savings, or a service fee, whichever is greater.
- Visit O'Connor & Associates →O'Connor & AssociatesTXRoughly 50% of the first year's savings, no upfront fee.
We earn nothing from these links. They are here because a flat-fee packet is the wrong answer for someone who wants the work done for them. How we make money