Honest comparison · 2026
AppealDesk vs AppealMyTax: which $49 property tax kit is better?
AppealDesk and AppealMyTax cost exactly the same — $49 flat, one time, no cut of your savings. So price is a wash. The real question is the evidence and when you see it: AppealMyTax shows your county assessment record and previews comparable-property evidence when available free, before you pay. AppealDesk says its packet uses MLS and public transaction data and delivers that packet after purchase.
The difference in one line
AppealMyTax shows you the evidence first, then charges you. AppealDesk charges you first, then shows you the evidence. Same $49 — opposite order.
| Feature | AppealMyTax | AppealDesk |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $49 flat, one time | $49 flat, one time |
| See your assessed value before you pay | Yes — free, no signup | No — shown after purchase |
| See comparable-property evidence before you pay | Yes when a usable cohort exists — the address check previews it free | No — evidence delivered after you pay |
| See your estimated savings before you pay | Yes — dollar figure up front | No |
| How the evidence source is described | Public county assessment records, with included parcels identified | AppealDesk says MLS and public transaction data |
| Coverage | Free address check discloses whether property-specific evidence is available | Claims all 50 states / 3,100 counties |
| Filing model | You file (sign-ready kit) | You file (packet) |
| Statute-cited protest letter | Yes — §41.43(b)(3) unequal appraisal, your account number pre-filled | Packet included |
| Recurring / contingency fee | None — you keep 100% | None — flat fee |
| Refund | 30-day refund | Refund terms on their site |
Both providers' pricing is their publicly listed $49 flat fee as of 2026; verify current terms on their site. AppealDesk product details reflect its public marketing pages.
Why seeing the evidence first is the whole game
A property tax protest is only as strong as its comparable sales. If a comp is wrong — a home that never sold, a property in the wrong neighborhood, or an estimate with no source — the review board can throw it out and you lose. That is why it matters that AppealMyTax pulls comps from your county's own appraisal roll, where every parcel is public and checkable, and shows you at least one in full before you spend a cent.
With a pay-first model you are buying the evidence sight unseen. With a check-first model you already know your assessed value, you have seen a real comp, and you know roughly what you stand to save — before the $49 ever leaves your account. If you are not over-assessed, you simply walk away and pay nothing.
Frequently asked questions
Is AppealDesk or AppealMyTax cheaper?
They cost the same: both are a $49 flat, one-time fee for a file-it-yourself property tax protest kit, with no contingency fee and no percentage of your savings. Because the price is identical, the real decision comes down to the evidence inside the kit and whether you can see it before you pay.
What is the actual difference between AppealDesk and AppealMyTax?
The clearest difference is the pre-purchase workflow. AppealMyTax's free address check shows the public county record and previews comparable-property evidence when a usable cohort exists. AppealDesk says its $49 packet includes comparable sales from MLS and public transaction data and is delivered after purchase.
Why does evidence provenance matter?
A homeowner should be able to identify the source and verify the properties used in an appeal. AppealMyTax identifies public county-record parcels and shows whether that evidence exists before checkout. AppealDesk publicly says it uses MLS and public transaction data; buyers should evaluate the delivered packet against their county's rules.
Is AppealDesk legit?
AppealDesk is a real $49 flat-fee product that sells a file-it-yourself evidence packet and claims nationwide coverage. AppealMyTax's differentiator is its free address-level evidence check: you see the county record and, where available, a comparable-property preview before deciding whether to buy.
Can I just check if I'm over-assessed without buying anything?
Yes. Enter your address to see the county assessment record and the evidence available for that property, with no signup or card. If the system finds a usable comparable-property cohort, it previews that evidence before purchase; otherwise it says what the $49 valuation report can still document.
Want the deeper teardown rather than the side-by-side? Read our full AppealDesk review, which digs into how their AI-generated comps are produced and where they break down. Or see how we stack up against the done-for-you firms on our full comparison hub, and the honest breakdown of every fee model.
See your real overpayment first — free
Before you pick any $49 kit, check whether you are even over-assessed. Enter your address and see your assessed value, a real comparable sale, and your estimated savings in about 30 seconds. No signup, no card.
Check my address, free